Module 5 Blog

Disney/ABC Controversy 

One brand that faced some ethical issues quite recently is the brand Disney (as well as many other brands associated with Disney, such as ABC and Hulu). Disney-owned ABC recently made a controversial— and arguably unethical— decision to indefinitely end the show “Jimmy Kimmel Live,” leaving countless people unemployed overnight. The decision was made in response to public pressure from the current authoritarian administration after Kimmel made comments that some guys named Brendan and Donald didn’t love hearing (Koblin et al., 2025).


Ethical Implications

However, in a country largely built on the right to freedom of speech, the move by ABC proved to be quite the ethical issue. Disney and ABC’s failure to provide reasoning for their decision only added fuel to the fire. Turns out, much of Disney and ABC’s audience doesn’t take kindly to rich white men’s freedom of speech being targeted by other rich white men. Plus, not liking what someone said on their talk show isn’t actually a crime in the United States, unbeknownst to some of our leaders in government. Many consumers of status fled to social media to publicly express their disagreement with Disney, ABC, and their decision. Hashtags like #StandWithKimmel and #CancelDisney started trending on social media as consumers began detailing their acts of protest: boycotting ABC and popular shows such as Dancing With The Stars, cancelling Disney+ subscriptions, and more. It has been reported that Disney lost about 1.7 million subscribers from their streaming services and the company’s valuation dropped by approximately $6.4 billion as a result of consumer backlash. Ultimately, Jimmy Kimmel Live was un-suspended and returned to ABC less than a week later (Saad, 2025).


Reflections

This entire ordeal— catering to the whims of emotionally dysregulated and immature politicians, losing millions of customers, losing billions in company value— could have been avoided by Disney and ABC entirely. If Disney and ABC had used the TBL framework for this decision, they might have decided to ignore complaints from Brendan and Donald, seeing as how the company profited from Jimmy Kimmel Live and was in fine financial standing prior to the decision, most consumers of Jimmy Kimmel Live (except for 2 random guys) view the show as a product that adds value to their lives, and that cancelling the show would not have any real benefit to the planet itself. Additionally, Disney and ABC could promoted their reputations and workplace cultures in a positive light by voicing support for their employee, Jimmy Kimmel, and the show they have all created together in the face of an attempted attack on our freedom of speech. Ultimately, if Disney and ABC were going to make this decision, staying silent about their reasoning only made matters worse. The brands could have released a statement describing less unethical reasons for ending a show, like when CBS cited financial issues as the reason for ending The Late Show with Stephen Colbert (Saad, 2025).


References:

Koblin, J., Grynbaum, M. M., & Barnes, B. (2025, September 17). ABC pulls Jimmy Kimmel off air for Charlie Kirk comments after F.C.C. pressure. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/09/17/business/media/abc-jimmy-kimmel.html 

Saad, N. (2025, September 23). Disney reinstates Jimmy Kimmel after suspension over Charlie Kirk remarks. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c701jr01dj2o

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Module 3 Blog: Market Segmentation

Module 6 Blog

A Day in the Life